Updated: November 22, 2026, 12:34 p.m. Eastern Time (ET; UTC−05:00).
A federal judge in Rhode Island ruled on November 20 that the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development exceeded its authority by reserving $1.3 billion in Continuum of Care (CoC) grants for new transitional housing and supportive-services projects. The court vacated the set-aside and ordered HUD to let communities revise Tier 2 applications by December 1. It also directed HUD to make Tier 1 awards by December 1 and Tier 2 awards by December 31.
The decision changes the rules for a roughly $4 billion national grant competition, but it does not cancel the appropriation or guarantee funding to any individual project. HUD had previously been allowed to proceed after an appeals-court stay; the new district-court order resolves additional challenges to the grant rules and sets a fresh process for Tier 2 awards. Read the November 20 court order and HUD’s CoC competition updates.
Destaques
- The court struck down HUD’s $1.3 billion set-aside for new transitional-housing and supportive-services-only projects.
- Communities may resubmit Tier 2 applications through December 1, 2026; HUD must issue Tier 2 awards by December 31.
- Tier 1 awards remain due by December 1, and the ruling does not guarantee any project’s funding.
- The case is about HUD’s authority under the homelessness statute and how it applies grant criteria, not whether Congress appropriated the money.
What did the court decide about HUD homelessness funding?
The CoC program, authorized by the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act, funds local and regional efforts to house people experiencing homelessness. Local Continuums of Care coordinate applications from nonprofit providers, governments, and other eligible organizations. HUD’s fiscal year 2026 competition made more than $4 billion available through a competitive Notice of Funding Opportunity, or NOFO.
HUD’s NOFO directed $1.3 billion toward new transitional-housing and supportive-services-only projects. In its November 20 order, the district court concluded that this set-aside conflicted with the statute’s required project-review factors, including prior performance and outcomes related to permanent housing. The court said HUD could not reserve most Tier 2 funding for selected project types before weighing eligible projects under the law’s required criteria. It vacated the set-aside and barred HUD from categorically prioritizing transitional housing, supportive-services-only, or new projects over existing or permanent-housing projects.
The order also invalidated several other provisions, including points for mandatory service participation, a definition of “self-sufficiency,” certain executive-order conditions, and two federal budget apportionment footnotes. The judge did not strike every service-related preference: the order distinguishes mandatory participation rules from provisions that award points for services or treatment partnerships. Those distinctions matter because the judgment is specific to the challenged language and its legal basis.
Why is the homelessness grant fight both legal and budgetary?
The legal question is whether HUD followed the authority Congress gave it. The court found that the statute requires HUD to consider specified factors when selecting projects, and that the $1.3 billion set-aside improperly placed some projects outside ordinary comparison for a large share of the Tier 2 pool. The court’s remedy is therefore about how funds are evaluated and awarded, rather than reducing the amount Congress appropriated.
The budget pressure comes from the scale and timing of the competition. HUD’s NOFO made $4.04 billion available, and the set-aside represented about 32% of that total. Communities had already developed priority lists and submitted applications under the earlier rules. The court found that the set-aside could have distorted which projects local CoCs chose to include, so simply removing the reservation would not fully restore a fair chance to compete. It ordered HUD to reopen Tier 2 submissions to address that problem.
Earlier in the case, the First Circuit temporarily allowed the NOFO to proceed while an appeal was pending. The district court’s August ruling had been stayed, then the appellate court vacated that judgment and remanded the dispute for further proceedings. In its latest November 20 ruling, the district court decided the remaining statutory and other challenges. That sequence explains why reports from September describing the NOFO as cleared to proceed do not reflect the newest order. The procedural history appears in the First Circuit’s September decision and the district court’s November order.
What could change for local housing providers and applicants?
For communities with Tier 2 projects, the immediate task is to check with the local CoC about whether and how to amend or resubmit an application before the court-ordered deadline. A project may now compete under revised priorities, but it still must meet eligibility thresholds and compete for finite funds. The order directs HUD to use each CoC’s latest application submitted by the deadline and to select eligible Tier 2 projects by score until funding is exhausted.
For providers, municipalities, and people relying on services, the practical effects will depend on the final awards. A change in selection criteria could affect which permanent-housing renewals, transitional-housing proposals, and service programs receive grants. It does not itself close a shelter, terminate a housing subsidy, or promise a new award. Existing grants and local plans have their own timelines, and the federal process remains subject to implementation and potential further litigation.
HUD had previously listed a December 11 award expectation, according to a local CoC update reporting HUD’s November 19 announcement. The court’s subsequent order now sets a December 31 deadline for Tier 2 award decisions and December 1 for Tier 1 awards. Communities should follow HUD’s competition page and official notices for implementation details, rather than rely on earlier timelines.
Frequently asked questions
Did the court cancel the $4 billion homelessness program?
No. It struck down the $1.3 billion set-aside and other challenged provisions. The CoC appropriation remains available for awards under the rules in the court’s order.
Can local organizations apply again?
Tier 2 applications may be amended and resubmitted through December 1, 2026, under the court’s order. Applicants should coordinate with their local CoC about the process and deadlines.
Does the ruling guarantee funding for permanent housing?
No. It prevents categorical preference for certain project types and requires lawful review of eligible Tier 2 projects. Awards remain competitive and depend on project eligibility, scores, and available funds.