Verified and updated: November 21, 2026, 10:03 a.m. CET (UTC+01:00).
The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled 9–8 on November 20 that the House violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause when it counted absent members represented by proxies toward a quorum for passage of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023. The immediate remedy is narrower than the constitutional holding: the court affirmed an injunction barring federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) against Texas. It did not invalidate the entire spending law nationwide. Read the Fifth Circuit’s opinion in State of Texas v. Blanche.
Destaques
- The en banc court held that proxy presence cannot satisfy the House’s constitutional quorum requirement.
- The 2022 House vote on the 2023 spending package was 225–201; 226 of 427 members who recorded votes did so by proxy.
- The judgment leaves the PWFA unenforceable against Texas under this injunction; it does not erase the statute for all employers or states.
- Further litigation or a Supreme Court petition could affect what comes next; the court’s opinion itself does not establish that such review has been sought.
What did the 5th Circuit decide about proxy voting?
In State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386, a divided en banc court concluded that the Quorum Clause requires members to be physically present to count toward a House quorum. The majority said the constitutional text, historical practice and Supreme Court precedent did not allow the House to treat an absent member’s proxy as presence for that purpose. It also rejected the federal government’s argument that the enrolled-bill rule prevented courts from reviewing this constitutional challenge.
The case concerns the House’s pandemic-era procedure. House Resolution 965, adopted in 2020, let a member designate another member to cast votes and record the absent member’s presence. The House continued a related proxy procedure into the 117th Congress. On December 23, 2022, it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, which became Public Law 117-328 after passage by the Senate and signature by the president. The Fifth Circuit’s opinion says the House tally was 225 yeas and 201 nays, and that 226 of the 427 members recording a vote on the measure did so by proxy.
What changed for the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act?
The Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court’s permanent injunction against applying the PWFA to Texas. The statute generally requires covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, absent undue hardship. The ruling means the federal government cannot enforce the PWFA against Texas under the affirmed injunction. The decision does not, by its terms, bar enforcement against private employers or other states.
That distinction matters because the lawsuit sought relief for Texas, not a nationwide order striking down every provision in the 2023 appropriations package. The appellate majority expressly described the judgment’s reach as limited to affirming the relief the district court granted. Other provisions of the appropriations law remain outside the injunction described in this case. Questions about whether another party can bring a separate challenge would depend on that case’s facts, claims and standing; the opinion does not itself decide those hypothetical disputes.
Why was the ruling divided?
The majority treated the quorum requirement as a constitutional limit that Congress cannot change through its internal rules. It reasoned that the House’s authority to set its procedures does not permit it to count absent representatives as present for this constitutional purpose. The court’s analysis therefore addressed whether the proxy rule could establish a quorum, not whether members could cast votes by proxy in every possible circumstance.
Eight judges joined the majority. The dissenting judges disputed the majority’s interpretation of the Quorum Clause and emphasized Congress’s power to determine its own proceedings. The split underscores that the ruling reflects a divided appellate court, rather than a unanimous resolution of the constitutional question. The earlier three-judge panel had ruled the other way in 2025; the en banc court granted rehearing and vacated that panel opinion before issuing this decision.
What happens next in the proxy voting case?
The practical next steps are not settled by the opinion’s release alone. The federal parties may seek further review, including asking the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the dispute, but the ruling does not establish that a petition has been filed or accepted. Until the litigation develops further, the order affirmed by the Fifth Circuit governs the PWFA’s enforcement against Texas, while the potential reach of the majority’s reasoning in other lawsuits remains an open question.
For employers and workers, the key is to distinguish the court’s constitutional reasoning from its remedy. The opinion raises a significant question about how a chamber may establish a quorum, but the judgment entered in this particular case is limited. Texas-specific enforcement consequences follow from the injunction; broader consequences would require additional legal action or a later ruling.
Frequently asked questions
Did the Fifth Circuit strike down the entire 2023 spending law?
No. The court affirmed an injunction barring enforcement of the PWFA against Texas. It did not invalidate the entire appropriations act nationwide.
Does the ruling apply to every employer?
No. The affirmed injunction concerns enforcement of the PWFA against Texas. The opinion does not impose a nationwide exemption for employers.
Has the Supreme Court agreed to review the case?
The Fifth Circuit opinion does not say that the Supreme Court has accepted the case. Further review remains a possible next step, not a confirmed event.