Verified and updated: November 21, 2026, 9:04 a.m. UTC.
The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled 9–8 on November 20 that the House of Representatives could not count members recorded as present by proxy toward a constitutional quorum when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023. The immediate consequence is limited: the court affirmed an injunction barring federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) against Texas. It did not erase the entire spending law or automatically invalidate every federal statute passed during the pandemic.
The decision could nevertheless invite new legal challenges. Its reasoning addresses the House’s quorum practice, while the remedy in this case concerns one law and one state. Whether other laws or claims are affected will depend on future cases, their facts, and any review by the Supreme Court.
Destaques
- The Fifth Circuit held that proxy presence did not count toward a House quorum under the Constitution’s Quorum Clause.
- The court affirmed relief for Texas concerning the PWFA, rather than striking down the entire 2023 appropriations act.
- The opinion may encourage challenges to other measures passed under the same pandemic-era House rule, but it does not decide those cases.
- Further appeals could change the legal picture; the ruling’s practical reach is currently tied to the dispute before the court.
What did the Fifth Circuit decide about proxy voting?
In State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386, the en banc court considered whether the House could count members who were not physically in the chamber as present for quorum purposes. The pandemic-era House rule let a member designate another member to cast a vote or record the absent member’s presence. The court concluded that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause does not permit those proxy appearances to establish a quorum.
The dispute concerns the December 2022 passage of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, a broad funding package that became Public Law 117-328. The opinion says the House’s final tally was 225 votes in favor and 201 opposed, and that 226 members recorded their presence and vote by proxy. The court accepted that the House established a quorum only by counting proxies.
The government argued, among other things, that courts should not review the constitutional challenge because the bill had been formally enrolled and signed. The Fifth Circuit rejected that argument in this case, reasoning that Texas raised a constitutional question about the quorum requirement rather than a factual dispute over whether the enrolled bill matched what Congress passed.
Does the ruling invalidate the entire 2023 spending law?
No. The court affirmed the district court’s injunction against enforcing the PWFA against Texas. The case did not result in an order nullifying every provision of the appropriations act nationwide. The opinion also describes Texas’s request for relief as limited to the PWFA; its separate challenge to a Department of Homeland Security pilot program was not pursued on appeal.
The distinction matters. A court’s constitutional reasoning may be cited in later litigation, but the judgment’s direct effect depends on the claim and remedy before it. Employers, workers, and public agencies should not assume from this ruling alone that every PWFA obligation has vanished everywhere. The act and the injunction’s application may raise different questions outside Texas, and later proceedings could clarify the scope.
What could happen to other laws passed by proxy?
The opinion creates a potential argument for litigants challenging other legislation passed when proxy presence was counted toward a House quorum. But a new plaintiff would still need a suitable case, standing, a legal basis to obtain judicial review, and an appropriate remedy. Courts could also confront distinct defenses or factual circumstances. The Fifth Circuit’s decision does not itself reopen every past congressional vote.
The ruling also sets up a broader constitutional debate. The majority emphasized the Quorum Clause’s text, historical practice, and Supreme Court precedent on attendance. The dissenting judges disputed that approach and raised concerns about both congressional authority to set procedural rules and the scope of the remedy. That disagreement signals that the issue may continue through further appeals.
Why does the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act matter here?
Congress enacted the PWFA as part of the 2023 spending package. It requires covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, absent undue hardship. Texas challenged enforcement against the state, arguing that the House had not constitutionally passed the law because proxy members were counted toward a quorum.
For workers and employers, the immediate practical question is geographic and legal: how the Texas-specific injunction applies, and whether other courts issue or uphold additional relief. Because the case is likely to attract further litigation, people affected by the act should consult current agency guidance and legal counsel for their circumstances rather than treating a broad headline as a nationwide ruling.
What happens next?
The Fifth Circuit’s November 20 opinion is the operative appellate decision in this case unless modified or stayed. The federal government may seek further review, including in the Supreme Court; the official opinion itself does not say that the Supreme Court has accepted the case. Future lawsuits may test whether the ruling’s reasoning extends to other laws. Until those steps occur, the safest description is that the court held the proxy quorum unconstitutional in this case and affirmed relief concerning enforcement of the PWFA against Texas.
Sources: Fifth Circuit opinion, State of Texas v. Blanche (Nov. 20, 2026); U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
FAQ
Did the court strike down the whole spending bill?
No. It affirmed an injunction addressing enforcement of the PWFA against Texas.
Does the ruling affect every state in the Fifth Circuit?
The direct relief in this case concerns Texas. The ruling’s reasoning may matter in later cases, but it does not automatically extend the injunction to every state.
Can the decision be appealed?
Further review may be sought. The court’s opinion does not establish that the Supreme Court has taken the case.