Verified and updated: November 21, 2026, 9:03 a.m. UTC.
An en banc panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled 9–8 on November 20 that the House violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause when it counted absent members voting by proxy to establish a quorum for passage of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023. The court affirmed an injunction barring the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) against Texas. The decision’s immediate legal effect is limited to that relief; it does not strike down the entire spending law or automatically invalidate other statutes passed during the pandemic.
For workers, employers, and public agencies, the practical question is therefore narrower than the ruling’s broad constitutional reasoning: how the Texas injunction affects PWFA enforcement, and whether other challenges follow. Read the Fifth Circuit’s opinion in State of Texas v. Blanche.
Destaques
- The Fifth Circuit held that proxy presence could not count toward a House quorum under the Constitution.
- The court affirmed an injunction against federal enforcement of the PWFA against Texas.
- The opinion does not invalidate the full 2023 appropriations act or all pandemic-era legislation.
- Further litigation or review could change the legal landscape; the ruling itself does not settle those future questions.
What did the Fifth Circuit decide?
In State of Texas v. Blanche, the full Fifth Circuit considered the House’s pandemic-era proxy voting procedure. Under the procedure, a member could designate another member to cast a vote and record the absent member’s presence. The court’s majority concluded that an absent member represented by proxy is not “present” for purposes of the Quorum Clause in Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution.
The dispute concerned the House vote on the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, a broad federal funding measure signed into law in December 2022. The opinion says the final vote was 225–201, with one member voting present and four not voting; 226 members recorded their votes and presence by proxy. Texas challenged the law’s application to the PWFA, which requires covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, subject to the statute’s terms.
The court also rejected the federal government’s argument that the enrolled-bill rule foreclosed this constitutional review. The majority reasoned that the challenge concerned the Constitution’s quorum requirement, rather than a dispute over whether the signed bill’s text matched what Congress passed. The official opinion sets out the court’s reasoning and the dissent.
Does the ruling end PWFA protections nationwide?
No. The court expressly said its decision extended no further than affirming the relief awarded by the district court: an injunction against enforcement of the PWFA against Texas. It did not issue a nationwide order, repeal the statute, or invalidate every part of the 2023 appropriations act. Texas’s separate challenge to a funding provision was not before the appeals court after the state did not pursue that issue on appeal.
That distinction matters in practice. Employers outside Texas should not treat the Fifth Circuit ruling as a nationwide exemption from the PWFA. In Texas, the decision changes the federal government’s ability to enforce that law against the state; the ruling does not, by itself, resolve every question about every employer, claim, or source of legal obligation. The opinion’s exact reach and any later court orders should be checked before making workplace decisions.
What could the decision mean for other federal laws?
The majority’s constitutional reasoning may encourage litigants to examine other provisions enacted as part of the same 2023 act, or to raise quorum arguments about other measures passed under pandemic-era House procedures. That is a possible litigation path, not an outcome established by this opinion. Any new challenge would face its own questions, including who has standing, what relief a court may grant, which court has jurisdiction, and whether the challenged law was enacted using the relevant procedure.
The ruling also does not automatically unwind completed government spending, benefits, contracts, or legal decisions. The court affirmed a specific injunction in a case brought by Texas. Other statutes and government actions remain in place unless they are changed by legislation or affected by a separate court order.
What should Texas workers and employers do now?
Workers seeking pregnancy-related accommodations and employers reviewing policies should avoid assuming that a court decision about federal enforcement resolves every individual situation. Check the current text of the injunction and any later orders, document accommodation requests and responses, and consult qualified counsel about applicable federal, state, and local requirements. Agencies and employers should also monitor whether the federal government seeks further review or issues implementation guidance.
For readers outside Texas, the immediate practical step is to continue checking official federal guidance and court developments rather than changing policies based only on the broad constitutional language in the opinion. The case concerns a specific federal enforcement injunction; it is not a general ruling that all remote participation in Congress is unconstitutional or that all laws passed during COVID are void.
What happens next?
The case is now subject to further legal developments, which may include a request for Supreme Court review. The reviewed opinion does not itself announce a stay or a pending Supreme Court decision. Until another court changes the result, the Fifth Circuit’s judgment affirming the Texas-specific PWFA injunction remains the operative result in this case. A future appeal could affirm, narrow, or reverse that outcome; those possibilities are forecasts, not current holdings.
The dissent underscored the stakes, arguing that the majority’s physical-presence rule goes beyond the text and that the remedy does not explain why only one part of the larger act is affected. That disagreement signals the constitutional issue is contested, while leaving the majority opinion binding within the Fifth Circuit unless altered through further review.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act invalid across the United States?
No. The injunction affirmed by the Fifth Circuit bars federal enforcement against Texas. The court did not invalidate the PWFA nationwide.
Did the court void the entire 2023 spending law?
No. The court affirmed relief limited to enforcement of the PWFA against Texas; it did not strike down the full appropriations act.
Could the ruling affect other laws passed during the pandemic?
Potentially, through future lawsuits. This opinion does not automatically invalidate other laws, and any challenge would require a separate court decision.