Is Gemini a complete Google Assistant replacement?

Even before Generative AI , it was clear that Google Assistant was on the back foot. Now that Google is in the “Gemini era,” what’s next for Assistant?

At its peak, Assistant was a connector between Google products. For example, “Google Assistant” was listed on the Pixel 3 spec page under “Operating System.” Assistant Driving Mode later replaced Android Auto on the phone’s home screen, but it ultimately flopped.

Around 2021 and certainly into 2022, it became clear that Assistant was no longer a big priority for Google. Google was specifically pulling back on Assistant experiences outside of its core voice capabilities. This included the Driving Mode Dashboard and Snapshot feed, as well as “Memory,” which was intended to enhance reminders and content storage on Android.

What is Google Assistant like today?

On Android phones, Gemini is emerging, and it's clear the company is focusing on this product. It's interesting how Google describes the difference:

  • Gemini, Google's experimental AI-powered assistant, can help you get creative and be more productive
  • Google Assistant is a voice-forward conversational assistant you can use to get things done.

That said, there are still a number of Assistant-branded experiences. Google's list includes:

  • When you receive information and updates from At a Glance.
  • When you use the microphone in the Google Maps app search bar, and when you activate the Google Assistant while navigating, such as by tapping the on-screen microphone or saying “Ok Google,” and when you're using the Google Assistant driving mode.
  • When you access Google Assistant from Android Auto by connecting your phone to your car's display.
  • When you use the microphone in the Waze app search bar and when you activate Google Assistant with the Waze app in the foreground.
  • On Gboard, when you use Assistant's voice typing feature.
  • When you receive an Android notification from a device with Google Assistant.

Looking at other form factors, this is still the primary way you interact with Google Assistant-enabled headphones, although we've seen signs that Gemini is coming. There's also Assistant on Wear OS, Android Auto and Automotive, Smart Displays, and speakers.

Does Google Assistant still work?

When “Assistant with Bard” was announced alongside the Pixel 8 in October, Google Assistant would act as the audio and visual interface that people actually interact with. The phrase “with Bard” implies that Google sees Generative AI as an added capability to Assistant rather than a complete replacement for it.

Once everything was fully integrated, the move should have been to drop the “with Bard” distinction and just offer “Google Assistant,” a timeless name. This approach would preserve the areas where Assistant excels.

Assistant can be compared to a car and Bard is a new engine to overhaul the main use case.

After the Gemini rebrand, it seems like Google is building a completely new tool from scratch, which leads to missing features, unwanted changes, and user frustration.

If Google were to replace Assistant with Gemini, we'd be in for a long transition, where Assistant would have to be meticulously replicated while maintaining feature parity. Even moving the option entirely on the phone would be quite difficult, and that's not a promising start.

Leave a Comment

5 Reasons to Try Google Gemini

5 Reasons to Try Google Gemini

While not as widely discussed as some of its competitors, Google's Gemini AI has a lot going for it — and here are five reasons why Gemini deserves your attention.

Googles Gemini Responds With Weird, Repeated Nonsense Words to Some Users

Googles Gemini Responds With Weird, Repeated Nonsense Words to Some Users

Recently, some users noticed that Google Gemini has been giving repetitive text, weird characters, and complete nonsense in some responses.

Apple may be preparing to integrate Gemini into Apple Intelligence

Apple may be preparing to integrate Gemini into Apple Intelligence

Code found in the newly released iOS 18.4 beta suggests Apple is preparing an alternative to the ChatGPT integration in Apple Intelligence, most likely Google Gemini.

Google Removes Gemini Access From Google App for iPhone

Google Removes Gemini Access From Google App for iPhone

The Google app for iPhone is about to become a little less useful as Google recently removed access to Gemini AI from that app.

Google Launches AI Video Creation Feature on Gemini

Google Launches AI Video Creation Feature on Gemini

Google has just announced that users can now create videos using artificial intelligence through its Gemini chatbot and the recently launched experimental tool Whisk.

How Gemini extensions help you work more efficiently on Google Workspace

How Gemini extensions help you work more efficiently on Google Workspace

You can use the Gemini extension feature to connect different Google apps to get more personalized responses and streamline your workflow.

Google is about to completely rename Bard to Gemini

Google is about to completely rename Bard to Gemini

In a somewhat surprising move, it appears that Google is dropping the “Bard” branding entirely on its upcoming web app and mobile experience, in favor of “Gemini” entirely.

How to Add Gemini to Improve Your Google Sheets Experience

How to Add Gemini to Improve Your Google Sheets Experience

Tired of spending hours creating spreadsheets and entering data manually? You'll be glad to know that you can use Gemini's creation features with Google Sheets to automate tasks and improve your overall experience.

After ChatGPT, Apple Wants to Integrate Google Gemini into iOS

After ChatGPT, Apple Wants to Integrate Google Gemini into iOS

Apple hopes to bring more AI models like Gemini to iOS 18 so users can choose between different models.

Why choose Galaxy AI instead of Gemini?

Why choose Galaxy AI instead of Gemini?

Not only is Samsung beating Apple and Google to the punch with its so-called AI phone — launching the Galaxy AI in early 2024 — but Samsung is also doing AI better than the Gemini, despite being based on Google software.

Create images for documents using Gemini in Google Docs

Create images for documents using Gemini in Google Docs

Google has taken another step toward its commitment to more deeply integrating AI technology into its Workspace tools.

Google Lowers Minimum Requirements for Gemini App

Google Lowers Minimum Requirements for Gemini App

According to Android Authority, Google has recently quietly reduced the minimum requirements, allowing phones running Android 10 or higher to install Gemini.

Google Renames Bard to Gemini, Launches Mobile App and New Ultra 1.0 Version

Google Renames Bard to Gemini, Launches Mobile App and New Ultra 1.0 Version

Google has just officially announced the rebranding of the Bard AI chatbot to Gemini, similar to the most powerful AI model the company is holding.

Gemini AI Can Now Watch YouTube Videos for You, Saving Hours of Time

Gemini AI Can Now Watch YouTube Videos for You, Saving Hours of Time

Google Gemini's recent update can now help you know what long YouTube videos are about without watching them.

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Error K Security

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Error K Security

Struggling with Microsoft Teams "Error K" Security? Follow our step-by-step guide to fix it quickly—no tech expertise needed. Get back to seamless collaboration today!

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Update Error 0x80070002

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Update Error 0x80070002

Struggling with Microsoft Teams Update Error 0x80070002? Discover step-by-step fixes to resolve it quickly. Clear cache, repair files, and get back to seamless updates today!

Solving Microsoft Teams Web Error Browser Login

Solving Microsoft Teams Web Error Browser Login

Tired of Microsoft Teams "Web Error" blocking your browser login? Follow our step-by-step guide with proven fixes to resolve Teams web login issues fast and securely. Get back to work!

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Error O Offline

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Error O Offline

Stuck with Microsoft Teams "Error O" Offline? Discover proven, step-by-step fixes to get back online fast. Clear cache, restart, and more – no tech skills needed!

Where is Microsoft Teams in Outlook? Locating the Missing Icon

Where is Microsoft Teams in Outlook? Locating the Missing Icon

Frustrated by the missing Microsoft Teams icon in Outlook? Learn exactly where to find it, why it disappears, and proven steps to restore it for effortless meetings. Updated for the latest versions!

Solving Microsoft Teams Windows 10 Error Login Issues

Solving Microsoft Teams Windows 10 Error Login Issues

Struggling with Microsoft Teams "Windows 10 Error" login issues? Get instant fixes for cache clears, updates, and more. Step-by-step solutions to solve Microsoft Teams login error on Windows 10 fast and frustration-free.

Solving Microsoft Teams Website Error Tab Not Loading

Solving Microsoft Teams Website Error Tab Not Loading

Tired of the frustrating Microsoft Teams "Website Error" where tabs won’t load? Get step-by-step fixes to resolve it quickly and boost your productivity. Essential troubleshooting for seamless Teams experience.

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Web Error 503 Service Unavailable

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Web Error 503 Service Unavailable

Tired of the frustrating Microsoft Teams "Web Error" 503 Service Unavailable? Discover proven, step-by-step fixes for Teams 503 error on web. Get back online fast with our expert guide. Works on all browsers!

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Win 7 Error Compatibility

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Win 7 Error Compatibility

Struggling with Microsoft Teams "Win 7 Error" compatibility? Discover step-by-step fixes to restore seamless video calls and chats on unsupported Windows versions. Quick, reliable solutions inside!

Troubleshooting Microsoft Teams Breakout Rooms License Errors

Troubleshooting Microsoft Teams Breakout Rooms License Errors

Master troubleshooting Microsoft Teams Breakout Rooms license errors with this step-by-step guide. Quick fixes for common license issues, admin checks, and prevention tips to get your meetings running smoothly.

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Version History Error

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Version History Error

Struggling with Microsoft Teams "Version History" Error? Discover proven, step-by-step fixes to restore access instantly. Clear cache, update Teams, and more—no tech skills needed!

Solving Microsoft Teams Joining Error: Meeting ID Not Found

Solving Microsoft Teams Joining Error: Meeting ID Not Found

Tired of the frustrating Microsoft Teams Joining Error: Meeting ID Not Found? Get step-by-step fixes to rejoin meetings fast. Updated with the latest Teams patches for seamless collaboration. Solve it now!

Troubleshooting Microsoft Teams Video Error Green Screen

Troubleshooting Microsoft Teams Video Error Green Screen

Struggling with Microsoft Teams "Video Error" green screen? Discover proven, step-by-step troubleshooting fixes for seamless video calls. Quick solutions inside!

How to Fix Microsoft Teams How Teams Works Tutorial Error

How to Fix Microsoft Teams How Teams Works Tutorial Error

Struggling with the Microsoft Teams "How Teams Works" Tutorial Error? Discover proven, step-by-step fixes to resolve it quickly. Clear cache, update, and more for seamless onboarding. Works on latest versions!

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Error Today on Windows 10

How to Fix Microsoft Teams Error Today on Windows 10

Tired of the frustrating Microsoft Teams "Error Today" on Windows 10? Discover proven, step-by-step fixes to resolve it quickly and restore smooth teamwork. No tech skills needed!